Harry Potter Grows Up

I may have waited months before reading the latest Harry Potter book, but I didn’t waste anytime with the latest movie. Friday night I was again in Leicester Square for the opening of the Goblet of Fire, this time minus the fan-boy signs.

Minor Spoiler Alert
My Goblet of Fire Review
Although Goblet of Fire is probably the best HP movie thus far, I couldn’t help but feel disappointed when I left the theatre. My expectations for this movie were high: the 4th book was my favourite, the premiere had me all jacked up, and I was giddy like a school girl in anticipation. Maybe I wanted too much, but the movie didn’t fulfill all my deepest desires.

The movie is already long (2 1/2 hours + previews) but I would have been happy with another 30 minutes of film. They cut so much to squeeze the 4th book into a movie. I think 20 minutes into the movie they were already on Chapter 14. The World Cup of Quidditch was condensed into a 5 minute clip that didn’t show any quidditch, Leprechauns, or Vela. What!? A Harry Potter movie without quidditch! By far the biggest disappointment in my mind.

No mention of SPEW, Barty Crouch’s odd behaviour, Percy, or Winky either. Most of the movie was spent portraying the Tri-Wizardโ€™s Tournament. That and all the teenage angst; the best part of the movie was seeing all the characters growing up and dealing with their hormones.

GoF is a more adult movie: it’s darker, hormonal, violent, and (believe it or not) sex-infused. Hogwarts no longer looks bright and magical, but rather gloomy and sinister. The kids are no longer cute and innocent, but on the pull looking to snog someone. There is no shortage of sexual innuendo, sex appeal, and steamy scenes.

I like the new direction this film took. It mirrors the books and works well with the characters getting older. I just wish they didn’t have to alter the plot and cut scenes to make the film. In short, I want more: more topless Harry and more blossoming Hermione, more pubescent fights and emotional outbursts, and more magical duels and good vs. evil. Give me a 4 hour movie. I can take it, I want it! At least put the qudditch back in.


  1. I felt the same about Quidditch. I was really hoping that it’d be in it. So upset that they completely skipped the whole thing and didn’t even explain about tracing who make the mark in the sky. So mad. In the end, I felt like the movie was too short and went by too fast since it cut out so much. I would have watched a 9-hour movie if they made it. They’re going to have some trouble making Order of the Phoenix too since it’s so long. More cutting, I suppose….
    But the movie was funny, at least. =) funnier than I remember the book to be.


  2. I was happier with the cuts to Goblet of Fire than I was with the cuts to Prisoner of Azkaban. The cuts to POA caused plot holes (i.e. Not explaining how Sirius knew that Wormtail was at Hogwarts). I didn’t notice any real plot holes in GOF, which made me very happy.
    I’ll admit that I was disappointed by the complete lack of Percy, though.


  3. If they don’t make Order of the Phoenix into like three movies, I think I will cry.
    My complaints were the same as yours – it’s awesome, but there wasn’t enough. When I left the theatre all of my friends were rubbing their eyes and complaining that it was “too long”, but I don’t think I so much as blinked once.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s